Sam & Deans motel room
Sam is sitting at his laptop.
Dean comes out of the bathroom.
DEAN: So what did you dig up
SAM ( looking discouraged ): Not Much. The boogeyman is a mythical creature often seen by young children, usually described as androgenos or taking shape of the child's worse fear.
Dean sits on his bed.
DEAN: But nothing on how to kill it ?
SAM: Nope. Hopefully Cas and Shell will have more luck with the library.
Sam sits back in his chair looking frustrated.
DEAN: You okay dude ?
SAM: No I'm not. I promised that little girl I would fix this.
DEAN: And we will. If it actually exists there's a way to kill or at least trap it.
Sam gets up out of his chair and stretches
SAM: Wanna go grab some food ? May take Cas and Shell awhile.
Dean gets up and heads toward the door
DEAN:May as well
SAM: I'll take my laptop and keep looking
Leaves motel room
Michelle is sitting at a table with a stack of books in front of her reading lore. Castiel returns to the table with more books.
CASTIEL: These are the last ones with references to the Boogeyman
MICHELLE: Awesome. Hope they contain something I haven't read already.
Castiel sits across from her and grabs a book.
CASTIEL: Everything I've read has been pretty vague.
Shell's cell phone buzzes. She takes it out reads a message then sticks it back in her pocket
Looks up at Shell clearly wanting to say something then decides against it
MICHELLE: Cas, Is there something on your mind ?
Castiel looks up again
CASTIEL: No, no. You ?
MICHELLE:Just killing this thing. ( still reading )
CASTIEL: I know the....
Michelle interupts Cas, jumping up from her chair
MICHELLE: I found something we need this book
Sam and Deans motel room
SAM: So according to this book the Boogeyman only takes boys...
CASTIEL: That explains why he left the little girl behind
MICHELLE: And it takes them to a different reality where eventually the kids become boogeymen themselves
DEAN: So can it be killed ?
SAM: Yeah it can, but it has to be killed by a child because children are what gives it it's power.
DEAN: What about the 2 missing boys. How do we get them back ?
MICHELLE: We have to open the portal and enter it's reality to find them.
CASTIEL: Now all we need is a kid to kill it.
SAM: I think I know who to ask.
The Parker home
Sam knocks at the door
The door opens revealing Cheyenne
Sam: Hey Cheyenne. Is your mom home ?
CHEYENNE: No she's still at work. If you need to talk to her you'll have to come back.
Dean, Cas and Shell come up behind Sam
SHELL: We actually need to speak to you
CHEYENNE: Who are you guys ?
DEAN: These are 2 of our associates, Agent Bonnie and Agent Clyde
Michelle kicks Dean
CHEYENNE: About what ?
SAM: Killing the monster
Inside the home
CHEYENNE: You want me to what ?
MICHELLE: It has to be killed by a child. We can't do it.
DEAN: But we can help. You won't be alone
SAM That's right
Cheyenne thinks about it for a moment
CHEYENNE: What happens if I don't
MICHELLE: Then kids in your town keep disappearing and your friend stay lost
Cheyenne takes a deep breath
CHEYENNE: How do I kill it ?
Castiel pulls out his angel blade
CASTIEL: This should work
CHEYENNE: Cool knife mister
DEAN: Be careful with that kid
SAM: Okay, let's go open the portal
Everyone follows Sam up the stairs and into the bedroom. Dean walks over and opens the closet
SAM:secretum rei aliud appareat nunc porta
a portal opens in the closet. Cheyenne takes Sam's hand
CHEYENNE: You'll keep me safe, right ?
DEAN: We all will. Everyone stay together and be careful
The Boogeyman's lair
The lair of the Boogeyman man was dark, dismal, and cold. Cheyenne shivered as they stood there trying to get their bearings. Sam takes off his coat and gives it to her
CHEYENNE: Thank you Sam.
SAM: Don't mention it kiddo
Dean turns on his flashlight.
DEAN: Everyone ready ?
MICHELLE: As ready as we're going to be.
DEAN: I'll take the lead, Cas you take the rear.
Dean starts moving forward occassionally stopping to look and listen
CASTIEL: This looks like it goes on forever.
In the distance a childs voice
SAM: What was that ?
CHEYENNE ( excitedly ): It sounded like Christopher!
DEAN: Let's keep moving It sounded like it was right up ahead.
A few minutes later the hunters come to a door Dean grabs the handle.
DEAN: Okay guys let's be on our toes.
opens the door. Inside he shines his light on 2 very frightened little boys.
CHEYENNE (yelling ) : Christopher
Runs over to him and gives him a hug
Sam:we have to get them out of here
At that moment they hear a loud growl behind them. They spin around to see the Boogeyman blocking the door.
DEAN ( yelling ): Shell protect the boys
Shell draws her knife blocking the boys Cas stands beside her.
SAM: Cheyenne we can wound it but remember you have to finish the job.
CHEYENNE ( with fear in her voice ): Okay, I'm ready.
Sam and Dean rush forward plunging their knives into the monster. It howls angrily and slams Dean against the wall Sam plunges his knife again and the Boogeyman grabs him by the neck and throws him on the floor. He reaches down to grab Sam again.
CHEYENNE ( shouting ): HEY YOU
The Boogeyman turns around and Cheyenne plunges the angel blade into his chest. He falls to the floor then vanishes.
CHEYENNE: I did it !
SAM ( rubbing his neck ): I knew you could.
Sam turns to look at Dean.
SAM; You okay ?
DEAN: I'll live.
Castiel walks over and retrieves his blade.
CASTIEL: Let's get these kids home.
Castiel's and Shell's motel room
The siblings sit around in a happy mood. Sam and Dean are drinking a beer, Michelle opting for a soda.
DEAN: Did you see the look on Mrs Parker's face when we walked out of the closet with those kids ?
MICHELLE ( laughing ): I thought she was going to faint.
SAM: The best part is those kids are safe at home tonight thanks to Cheyenne.
DEAN: Kind of sad though. Those kids lost their innocense. Now they know monsters exist They'll never be the same.
SAM: Especially Cheyenne. Wish there had been another way.
Shell: Me too.
The siblings all sit quietly for a moment, thinking of their own unusual childhood.
DEAN: Well I'm beat.
SAM: Same here. Goodnight guys
Sam and Dean leave closing the door behind them;Michelle turns to look at Cas who has been sitting on the bed quietly. She walks over and sits down on his lap wrapping her arms around his neck.
MICHELLE: We need to talk. There's something I need to tell you.
CASTIEL: About why you've been sick ?
MICHELLE: Yes I ( pauses ) but you know already don't you
CASTIEL: Yes, but I don't understand Why were you trying to keep it a secret. Did you think I would be angry or not care ?
MICHELLE: I wasn't trying to keep it a secret. I was waiting for the blood test to be sure. The message I got today at the library were the results. I was waiting for the right moment to tell you. No time like after a Boogeyman hunt, right ?
Castiel smiles at her
Lays her head on Cas's shoulder
MICHELLE: So you're okay with this ?
CASTIEL: Of course I am
Puts his arms around her as they sit there planning for their little miracle.