Fan Rants

Even if we're totally in love with something we will always find flaws. Here are some rants I, and others, feel about things we adore.

25Likes
58Comments
3475Views
AA

23. TTT: The battle of Helm's Deep

In the Books: 1000 men against several thousand orcs

In the Films: 300 men were joined by 500-2000 elves against 10,000 orcs

In the Books: Gimli's score=  42, Legolas's score= 41

In the Films: Legolas's score= 42, Gimli says 43 but its made to look like he wasn't telling the truth just being annoying or something

In the Books: Eowyn was left at Meduseld to take charge of Rohan if both Theodon and Eomer who had just been named the heir died in Helms deep. Some men were left behind at Edoras also to help defend it. Theodon went to helms deep only to help Erkenbrand of the Westfold

In the Films: Eowyn was at Helm's Deep, no men were left at Edoras and Erkenbrand was left out or didn't exist in the films. Theodon went to Helms Deep to flee from Edoras as his people would be safer there but lost many men in the ambush because Grima Wormtongue knew what Theodon would decide

In the Books: Eomer was imprisoned for threatning Grima because Grima wanted his sister Eowyn, and was realesed after Grima was uncovered by Gandalf. He was at the battle of Helm's Deep. Gandalf was away fetching Erkenbrand and the men if the Westfold who were scattered

In the Films: Eomer was banished for threatning Grima because he realised Grima was working for Saruman and Grima wanted his sister Eowyn. He collected men of his house and rode North. Gandalf missed the Battle of the Hornburg because he was fetching Eomer and his men

In the Books: Merry and Pippin were freed from the Uruk-Hai by Eomer collecting men of his household and going off to fight raiders against orders. He lost fifteen men and twelve horses. He met Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli just after fighting the Uruk-Hai. He offered them three horses but Gimli refused to ride so he went on the back of Legolas's horse

In the Films: Eomer was out with men of his household whilst finding Theodred. Merry and Pippin were freed from the Uruk-Hai by Eomer collecting men of his household and leaving with them when he was banished. He and his men rode north and dealt with raiders on the way. He met Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli just after fighting the Uruk-Hai. He gave them two horses and Gimli went on the back onf Legolas's horse

Also, in the Films it would have been a better decision to let the strong women fight instead of the boys who weren't going to kill a single Uruk and would make no difference except a bigger loss of life on the Rohan side

TOO MANY CHANGES AND PEOPLE ADAPTING THE STORY!!!!

Join MovellasFind out what all the buzz is about. Join now to start sharing your creativity and passion
Loading ...